Hey, you're new! I love new people, welcome.
You may want to subscribe to Baby-Log via RSS feed or via email. Thanks for visiting!
My friend had a fight with her husband. She asked him to take over their child while she attends to other business and then overheard him on the phone refusing an invitation to go out “because he has to babysit”. She was furious and screamed at him: “You can’t say babysitting about your own child, it’s not a chore, it’s called parenting!”
When I heard that story, it made me think – in our family the Dad does 50% (if not more) of the parenting, but I know for a fact that in the other families it’s not so. The jokes about a Dad feeding kids chocolate cake for breakfast are there for a reason and indeed, many Dads never seize to amaze moms with their inability to care for their kids. We too have some issues about who does certain things better and how they should be done, but it’s not set in stone that MY way is the right way.
We share the tasks in a rational way – everyone does what he’s good at and what he enjoys. Well, apart from nappy-changing, that’s split 50-50 because after a 1000 nappies we both have the same level of expertise, as to enjoying it, let’s not go there :)
I cook for Eric (sometimes Rob does too), we both feed him, both read to him and play with him, go to walks and the playground. Rob gives him an evening bath, puts him to sleep, and if Eric wakes up at night we take turns. I wash his clothes and Rob puts them on line to dry.
I know that Rob can make strange decisions about the kind of games Eric is allowed to play and he can feed him something I wouldn’t think of – but does that necessarily make his choices bad or unacceptable? If my boy is coming home covered with dirt because he’s been helping daddy gardening, should I get mad and scream at them both?
It seems to me that the basic problem here is not the lack of parental skills some Dads are famous for. The problem is the lack of respect some Moms have for the Dads’ ideas, instincts, choices and the process of adjusting to and learning about parenthood.
And then there is another issue – some moms have this mental picture of incompetent Dad stuck in their minds and are not willing to let him try. Frankly, I can’t blame them so much, because being a mom myself I know that time is always an issue. What if we let Dad do something and all he makes a mess, do we have time to clean up after him? What if we ask him to manage something, he forgets, and we won’t have time to do it ourselves?
For what it’s worth, moms, you could try this: think of a Dad as a child – you don’t get mad at a child if he’s making a mess while eating, because it’s important for him to master that skill, right? And if he falls and gets mud on his clothes, you can’t punish him because he is learning how to walk, right? The more room you give him, the less he will feel watched and the more confidence he’ll be able to build, getting better at the same things you already do so well. Don’t be afraid to delegate things, make stuff his responsibility, the more you can re-assign to him – the more “free” time you’ll have.
How do you feel about leaving your kid with your husband for a day? How does parenting work in your family?
24 Responses
LaToya
March 18th, 2009 at 9:18 pm
1I would not leave my children alone with my husband at all. And that’s not doubt in my mind on his abilities . . . he’s a terrible father. I do 150% of the parenting.
Emma
March 20th, 2009 at 2:59 am
2I guess I am just lucky to be blessed with a husband who takes 50% of the parenting. That probably doesn’t put me in a good position to be giving tips on how to help the Dad become a better father, now does it? How come your husband is such a no-good father, what is it that he does (or doesn’t do)?
Skeptical Parent Crossing #6
March 21st, 2009 at 12:22 pm
3[…] Fatherhood. Emma asks if some of these assumptions are encouraged and perpetuated by the moms, in Dads: Parenting or Babysitting? And Dan’s t-ball coaching adventure illustrates that even doing a traditional […]
Estherar
March 22nd, 2009 at 7:37 am
4One of the reasons I was attracted to my husband in the first place was because he was such a good uncle. It indicated to me that he would be a capable father as well…and he is most certainly NOT a mere babysitter!
Aerik
March 23rd, 2009 at 12:39 pm
5Well no shit. If a person calls watching their own child “babysitting”…. fuck’em. Just fuck’em. That is not just a bad attitude. It is not just “learning to be a parent.”
There are some things you should just be expected to have learned by the time the pregnancy comes full term. One of those things is that you are a parent, and not a babysitter. Your job is not just to keep the damn thing alive until it’s mommy gets home. When a father refers to it as “babysitting,” what he is saying is that he’s not personally involved in parenting. He is saying he is not a parent.
Anybody man who does this shit… yes, your friend is right. His ideas don’t deserve respect. Because he doesn’t respect his own impact on his child.
And all you can do is whine that some moms must have a stereotype of bad fathers? Sure is a nice little nitpick for you to have. So very privileged, yes. Your father seems to do real parenting. “My dad does well, therefore all these moms complaining about obviously poor fathers are just stereotyping bitches.”
Fuck. you.
Why the fuck should it be that a mother who has learned how to be a parent by the time she gives birth is just being a nagging chore of a woman simply for expecting her husband to have caught up by the time the child can talk? Bullshit. Seems instead that you’ve internalized some prejudicial disrespect for mothers.
Sincerely,
a young man with real empathy skills.
Emma
March 23rd, 2009 at 11:08 pm
6I like people who are not afraid to express how they really feel! I don’t necessarily like your language but hey, nobody’s perfect. Still, I stand behind my opinion – it seems to me that many of “bad fathers” turned to be that way because their attempts to do stuff for the kids were dismissed by women who “know better”. I have to hold my own tong every time I want to say to my husband – “No, that’s not the way to do this”, so I know what I’m talking about. And you must acknowledge that if a person is being told 100 times “you’re a bad father” there’s a good chance they will become exactly that, a bad father.
SarahNicole
March 24th, 2009 at 10:47 am
7I think it’s pretty accurate to say that some women do indeed protect the mothering/domestic sphere turf, and and that they don’t do this because their husbands necessarily lack parenting or domestic skills. In research I did back in the late 90s, I certainly found that to be the case, and folks like Hochschild and Machung (and many others) have had similar findings as well (e.g. in the book The Second Shift). I have a tendency to do this, but possibly because I’m a control freak in general rather than as part of my gender identity/strategy — my husband knew how to cook one traditionally understood dish when we met: lasagna. When he started to take over cooking during my pregnancy, I taught him some basics, and now I eat what he makes — it’s simpler and less recipe-driven than what I would make, but it’s also more well-balanced, since he goes heavy on steamed veggies and baked meats… I’ve also learned to love getting my clothes out of a randomly folded pile atop my dresser. I’m going to be fairly well covered in spit up and such by day’s end, so I’m not caring so much about wrinkles. This all may change up again as I get regular sleep patterns and a consistent schedule again, but it will likely not revert to me doing the bulk of the cooking…
My husband does 50% of the parenting, and way more than 50% of the domestic duties at present, and 90% of the time he is out and about with our son, it is other people — men and women — who say to him, “Oh, you’re babysitting today!” and “Giving mom a break, are you?” It drives him mad, and sooner or later he’s going to come back with, “Why no, I’m parenting my child, you twit.” :-D
LaToya
March 24th, 2009 at 2:10 pm
8Emma, my husband does nothing. And I do mean nothing. I think he may give the boys about 30 minutes of his time a week on the rare occassion that he decides to be in the house. When we were dating he was really good with my nephew, once we got married he showed himself to be a completely different person. Who knows?? I can only hope for the boys sake that he gets it together one day.
I think you have a valid point and opinion though about not putting the father down when they try.
Emma
March 25th, 2009 at 8:12 am
9@SarahNicole: There you go, I knew somewhere there is a study to back me up :) And yes, the other people thing, I totally hate it myself. They really get to my husband too saying something like: “what about a real job”, or “when are you finally going to give up your nanny job”. Heck, what do they know about parenting anyway?
SarahNicole
March 26th, 2009 at 9:57 pm
10Heh. My husband just informed me that he actually knows how to make pie. And eclairs. After nearly six years together, he’s been hiding pie-making skills from me! I have extracted a pie promise from him for this weekend.
:-D
Emma
March 28th, 2009 at 4:54 pm
11I am hopeless in the kitchen and am taking cooking lessons from my husband :) He loves food and cooking. We often joke that he’s my knight in a shiny apron :)
antimattr
March 29th, 2009 at 12:55 pm
12I know that some men have been raised to avoid what was called “women’s work” in their home, but some of us men actually enjoy being parents and spending time with our kids. I guess I’m more “domestic” than most dads-I love to cook, I love having a clean house and expect to be responsible for sharing the cleaning (I actually probably do more than 50%), so I don’t understand how some men can shirk responsibility.
For me, spending time with our daughter is some of the best use of my time that I can imagine.
Emma
March 29th, 2009 at 9:00 pm
13@Antimattr: Finally, a comment from a DAD! My husband sure appreciates your support, thanks for putting your hand up. It kills me to see most people show disrespect to Rob because he does his share of “women’s work”. Go domestic Dads, you rock, guys!
PhilB
April 6th, 2009 at 2:01 pm
14So as a new dad of a 3 week-old….
Emma, while I agree with the spirit of the “think of Dad like a child…”. This is a nasty analogy. Especially first-time parents, no matter how many parenting books either parent has consumed through-out the pregnancy, all of parenting is a learning process for moms and dads. Most especially as a response to Aerik’s statement that dad’s should have learned how to be a parent by the time their baby’s popped out into the world, parenting to me seems to be a constant learning process of adapting to what works and for what works for the age the child is at. By the time we have parenting of a newborn down then that newborn is now a 1 year-old with entirely different needs.
That said, I do think that the pervasive culture making it a possiblity and also moral imperitive to be the perfect mother seems to contribute here to discouraging dad’s involvement. Increasing the recognition that we can’t be perfect parents for our children, but do the best we can using the tools and community at our disposal, can only help moms stress less and allow for their child’s dad to learn parenting in their own way and bring their own strengths to the table.
Emma
April 7th, 2009 at 5:26 am
15@PhilB
The analogy was supposed to convince moms to be more patient, more willing to share their expertise and experience – it was not supposed to make dads feel inferior. And I agree, there is no parenting book that will make you a great parent, only trial and error will.
PhilB
April 7th, 2009 at 9:01 am
16Emma, I think my point was mainly that new mom’s have about the same expertise and experience of new dads. The only major difference it seems is the cultural belief that women have an innate parenting instinct that men don’t have.
Emma
April 8th, 2009 at 8:43 am
17@PhilB Oh I think you’re totally right. And yes, people expect the new mom to immediately pick up and somehow “know” what to do with the newborn. I recon that a new dad can be much better than a new mom at things, such as trimming the infant’s nails or bathing, things that a new mom can be terrified of in the beginning (I remember I was!). But it so happens that a mom learns more than a dad in the same period of time if she spends more time with the baby. Let’s say a mother has a parental leave of at least 6 weeks, whereas a dad usually takes a week off and then returns to work. Those 6 weeks are a lot of time to learn all kinds of skills and to develop a better understanding of a newborn, and to read a lot of parenting books and magazines.
May’s Woman to Woman Blog Carnival « Homespun Healers
May 20th, 2009 at 11:54 am
18[…] Carnival Submission –> <p> <b>Emma</b> presents <a href=”http://www.baby-log.com/my-baby-day-by-day/dads-parenting-or-babysitting/” >Dads: parenting or babysitting?</a > posted at <a […]
Kelly
May 25th, 2009 at 5:19 pm
19I always leave my daughter with my husband. When he is home I give myself at least 2 hours a day to myself. I have found I am a stronger mother, wife and woman when I do this. This also allows the two of them to bond with one another and builds his confidence as a father. My husband is amazing and although parenting does not come easy or naturally for either of us, we do our best to figure things out as a team!!!
Emma
May 25th, 2009 at 5:45 pm
20@Kelly: This makes so much sense, even a little break makes me a better mother too, I noticed.
Discovering Dad Blog Carnival – July 2009 : Discovering Dad
July 12th, 2009 at 9:57 am
21[…] presents Dads: parenting or babysitting? posted at […]
Rudy
July 17th, 2009 at 4:55 pm
22I think expectations are important.
When our first child was born, I was clueless on how to be parent. I thought my job was to be a supportive husband and takes care of my wife. I go to the office 9 hours a day, come home exhausted, but managed to help out wash the dishes, take out the trash, etc.
But then my wife wanted me to do more. She wanted me to wake up in the middle of the night to comfort my baby. She wanted me to change diapers. Give baths. Basically everything she would do – except for breast feeding (for obvious reasons).
She just expected me to do it, but never told me. I was labeled a “lazy dad” for the first year, because I didn’t know she wanted me to do more parenting and house chores. It wasn’t fair and I fought her on the issue several times. Shouts and tears were common back then.
Now, I’m glad to say that we’ve come to a compromise. She has stopped assuming I know how to read her mind. She has stopped expecting me to be perfect in everything. I have learned to bite my tongue, and pick my battles. I have learned not to let my wife be “the boss” in the house, and learned to do what Moms do.
I have to learn to give more than to take. And that always work.
Emma
July 19th, 2009 at 1:07 am
23Hey Rudy, you’ve just said a very important thing there – “she stopped assuming I know how to read her mind”. That is SO true that we (girls) assume you guys know what you’ve done wrong when we give you “the look”. My life became so much happier and easier when I started to speak to my husband instead of being silently angry with him for whatever reason.
christian parenting
August 6th, 2009 at 4:14 am
24I leave my daughters with my husband for a few hours when he goes home. Like Kelly said, I need a few hours for myself too. My husband is not a perfect in looking after the girls but I see it in my daughter’s eyes that they have so much fun with him and looks forward for this moment everyday.
RSS feed for comments on this post · TrackBack URI
Leave a reply
Categories
Archives
Links
Meta
Subscribe via RSS
Get Baby-Log via RSS feed
Subscribe via email
IComLeavWe: Join the Conversation
Recent Entries
Recent Comments
Most Commented
http://www.Baby-Log.com 2008-2016 All rights reserved - I might give you some, if you ask nicely!
Baby-Log is proudly powered by WordPress - BloggingPro theme by: Design Disease